The main advantages of rubber or PVC litter mats are durability, easy to clean with water, non-absorbent, do not require any drying process. This kind of mats does not absorb any spills of urine.
However, rubber and PVC mats are rigid and hard for a cat to walk and sometimes this leads to avoidance of the litter box.
The major advantages of fabric or microfiber mats are soft surface and good acceptance by cats. Absorption ability of this mats allows to control the spills, however such mats need to be cleaned regularly and they may have unpleasant smell. Silicone litter mats have properties of both.
For most cases, the choice should be made in favor of soft-textured rubber or silicone litter mat with honeycomb or double-layer design.